Shop for Philadelphia Eagles gear at

Andy Reid, On the Hot Seat?


After finishing with an 8-8 record, some analysts, and fans, are calling for the Reid era to end. Missing the playoffs for two of the past three years, and coming in dead last in what is, arguably, the toughest division in the NFL. (if it is not, then it’s a close second to the AFC South) It is easy to see why people would think he is on the hot seat. This just isn’t the case with Reid.

Andy Reid is not only the best coach the Philadelphia Eagles have ever had, (his only flaw being the lack of championships), he is also one of the top coaches in the NFL. As far as the franchise goes, (according to Reid has a total of 96 wins, a .620 win percentage, making him the most winningest coach in franchise history. As far as the league goes, Reid is 16th all-time, and third among active coaches with at least 100 games coached. (Tony Dungy and Bill Belichick come in first and second)

Let’s not stop there though. Reid has the most playoff wins in franchise history with 8, while capturing the NFC East division title five times in six years. He coached the Eagles to four consecutive NFC Championship games, captured the NFC championship once, and led the Eagles to their first Super Bowl appearance in 24 years. He has been named NFL Coach of the Year twice, in 2000 and 2002.

So why is Reid on the hot seat? Well, from my perspective, he’s not, but let us look at it from someone else’s point of view. Reid missed the playoffs two out of the past three years. The two years that he didn’t make it, the team only went 14-18, mostly because of mediocre offenses, and the reason for that was usually because of injury to franchise quarterback, Donovan McNabb. Another point made by those who think this is Reid’s make or break season, is that the Eagles made it to four NFC championship games and one Super Bowl appearance without a win. No parade down Broad Street, no ring, no trophy. Well, we’re all disappointed at this, but it doesn’t mean that he won’t get us a Super Bowl win. Bill Cowher had a similar circumstance in Pittsburg, until he finally won the big one in 2005.

Reid has been the best thing to happen to the Eagles, period. He brought in possible future hall of famer, Donovan McNabb. Not to mention, he has had some of the best drafts in all of my years as an Eagles fan. He has found gems like DE Trent Cole in the 5th round, (12.5 sacks and his first pro-bowl last year), Brian Westbrook in the third round, (who is now one of the top three running backs in the league, and possibly the most dangerous player on the field), and Stewart Bradley in the 3rd, who we hope will live up to the expectations we have of him after the game against the Saints last year. (He became the first rookie to get his first interception and first sack in his first career start.)

He has also brought in big first day bangs, such as, QB Donovan McNabb, G Shawn Andrews, and CB Lito Sheppard. Reid has put together one of the best teams in the league, and it is only a matter of time until he gets us our first Super Bowl title. He has done everything to turn the Eagles from constant losers into perennial winners. He deserves the chance to take this team back to the Promised Land, and he’s earned the right to do it without us calling for his resignation.

Enjoyed this post?
Subscribe to Eagles Gab via RSS Feed or E-mail and receive daily news updates from us!

Submit to Digg  Stumble This Story  Share on Twitter  Post on Facebook  Post on MySpace  Add to  Bark It Up  Submit to Reddit  Fave on Technorati

7 Responses to “Andy Reid, On the Hot Seat?”

  1. Brandon Barney says:

    Stewart Bradley was a third round pick. Also, if discussing Reid’s genius moves, his failures such as McCoy and Fred-Ex must be mentioned.

  2. dageenphilly says:

    i also think reid is the best coach for the eagles.everybody should just get off his back.

  3. dave says:

    i’m gonna but into reid one more year. i do think he has a very good team this year, but championships are the bottom line. this team, for me, HAS to show superbowl potential. nothing short of the n.f.c. champ-game. as a fan, i need a super bowl victory to shut up the local scab fans. always eagles

  4. Jason says:

    I agree. Reid has another year to fix this. If not, something has to change. I don’t know if it should be a coaching change, or a QB change, but we better get to deep in the playoffs.

  5. j hernandez says:

    reid is the best thing that has happened to the eagles he may not be perfect but who is reid is awesome man if you like him when he is winning then you have to support him when he is loosing if you bleed green you will stand by him and watch the eagles kick some you know what this season eagles 11-5 baby

  6. D.Johnson says:

    I whole heartedly agree. If you bleed green then you must support Andy Reid wheather were winning or loosing. The coaching staff knows what they need to do. I believe they have done that this year with the draft and free agency. Go Eagles!!!

  7. dave says:

    i bleed green too, but if it wasnt for Garcia, were out of the play-offs for 3 straight years! i love andy but i love my birds more. they HAVE to show bowl potential.

Leave a Reply